Alright. So. They wanted feedback. So i'm here to offer some help and get some responses back.
As somebody who worked VERY hard the first time around and almost didn't sleep, i'm proud of the title I have. I love Ishgard, and the Firmament. However, I remember them saying that if you got it the first time around, you wouldn't need to do it again. As you would have the title and achievement to give room for others to have a chance. This brings up a problem. Their proposal this time around is change the first achievements name, making it and the new one unique. Therefore giving separate titles. While i'm ultimately fine with this (As if it comes to it, I WILL grind to get that as well), as stated before it doesn't let others get a chance who lost last time. As those same power house crafters who are fed materials (the same who won first round) will do it again for another unique title. My solutions are as follows.
1) Give the achievement to the first rounders as well. Freeing them up from being competitive this time around and allowing new people to come claim a title for themselves as well. This would leave first rounders open to gather or do other content and those who lost previously who do not have fed mats or the like would be given a second chance at claiming prizes from the boards.
This IS controversial in proposal i'm sure. But seeing how we were told we wouldn't have to again, I think it's a fair trade off to allow others a chance.
2) Keep the titles the same. While i'm okay with this, I know others MIGHT NOT BE. But it would, again, allow others a chance to get in there and get what they couldn't last time. And would thin the pool of competitors a bit. There will still be those who are pushing numbers just for the sake of pushing steps on Firmament. But it would still help quite a bit in the long run for those who lost.
Ultimately, the only other option they have is leave it how they proposed. but people like me will do everything we can (Having people gahter and give mats or buy as much as we need from the market) to get the unique rewards. Shadowing those less likely to compete by those means. I'd love some feedback here from you guys to help them help us. Thanks for taking the time to read it!
Continue reading...
As somebody who worked VERY hard the first time around and almost didn't sleep, i'm proud of the title I have. I love Ishgard, and the Firmament. However, I remember them saying that if you got it the first time around, you wouldn't need to do it again. As you would have the title and achievement to give room for others to have a chance. This brings up a problem. Their proposal this time around is change the first achievements name, making it and the new one unique. Therefore giving separate titles. While i'm ultimately fine with this (As if it comes to it, I WILL grind to get that as well), as stated before it doesn't let others get a chance who lost last time. As those same power house crafters who are fed materials (the same who won first round) will do it again for another unique title. My solutions are as follows.
1) Give the achievement to the first rounders as well. Freeing them up from being competitive this time around and allowing new people to come claim a title for themselves as well. This would leave first rounders open to gather or do other content and those who lost previously who do not have fed mats or the like would be given a second chance at claiming prizes from the boards.
This IS controversial in proposal i'm sure. But seeing how we were told we wouldn't have to again, I think it's a fair trade off to allow others a chance.
2) Keep the titles the same. While i'm okay with this, I know others MIGHT NOT BE. But it would, again, allow others a chance to get in there and get what they couldn't last time. And would thin the pool of competitors a bit. There will still be those who are pushing numbers just for the sake of pushing steps on Firmament. But it would still help quite a bit in the long run for those who lost.
Ultimately, the only other option they have is leave it how they proposed. but people like me will do everything we can (Having people gahter and give mats or buy as much as we need from the market) to get the unique rewards. Shadowing those less likely to compete by those means. I'd love some feedback here from you guys to help them help us. Thanks for taking the time to read it!
Continue reading...