While I realize people were pissed at him winning AF2 Hat, and many people doubt his skills, I'll say this.
He was the Whm for a party and I don't think even had refresh or ballad. To the best of my knowledge he kept his party alive reasonably well, attended the entire run, didn't complain in /l or /p, sucked up the wipes, the bad pulls, the animated weapons, the xp loss.
By DX's current rules what did he do wrong aside from looking like he forgot some gear in storage? While he was likely attending just for his AF2 Hat, which he obviously won, and may have just been a cherrypicker it is entirely this type of reason we're working on new lot rules.
But that being said I don't think he deserves bashing for the other night, he did nothing wrong, outside of his gear, and he didn't do anything that 1/2 the people attending sometimes have in mind, winning AF2 & splitting.